I'm sure I'll get a lot of downvotes on this one, but I have to say it.

In programming, most of the communities like Reddit, Stackoverflow and DailyDev have an upvote/downvote system, and in this article, I'll say why this is a nonsensical pyramid scheme that has the only purpose of inflating ego.

How the votes work

It's very simple:

• Someone upvotes your post/comment/answer and your reputation increases

• Someone downvotes your post/comment/answer and your reputation decreases

But here's the trick part: It's only valid when it's coming from someone with high reputation.

The problem

By allowing only the people with high reputation to give reputation to others, you segregate your users and build a monopoly of reputation. Only the ones approved, chosen by the gods, are worth to have their voices listen.

This leads to very toxic communities, the best example is StackOverflow, where most of the mods are there only to inflate their egos and not to help. This is a disfavor for all the dev community.

The solution

Rate limiting

These platforms already have a rate limiting system, where you can post / interact just a couple of times a day. By enforcing hate limiting, like "you can only give reputation to someone 1 time a day", this would cut most of the bots.

Behavior analysis

To increase even more the security, what I think that it's always necessary, you could do checks to see if someone is creating fake accounts with very suspicious behavior:

• Only giving reputation to a specific set of people

• if their account's only purpose is to upvote

Conclusion

Things would be more susceptible to bots? Yes, for sure, but I think that it's better to give voice to the people and moderators to ban the bots than creating a niched club of selected people.

I personally hate how this incentivizes division, superiority of a few and dominance instead of community, collaboration and knowledge share.

These "communities" are more like stages to a few people to have their egos massaged than a place to share knowledge and help each other.