Python package conflicts
Rakan
Posted on September 5, 2024
When developing a Python package, users might encounter dependency conflicts if different versions of the same dependency are required. For example, if your package requires requests==2.26.0
, but the user's system needs requests==2.25.1
, both cannot coexist since Python doesn’t allow multiple versions of the same package to be installed simultaneously.
Approaches to Avoid Dependency Conflicts:
A. Vendor Approach:
- Vendoring Dependencies: This involves including necessary dependencies directly in your package. It's useful for controlling versions but may increase package size.
- Pure-Python Packages: Vendoring works well for pure Python packages without their own dependencies.
- Packages with Dependencies: Vendoring becomes problematic if the vendored package has its own dependencies, leading to potential conflicts.
Issues:
- Dependency Clashes: Vendoring a package with dependencies may lead to conflicts in the user's environment.
- Version Control: Keeping vendored dependencies updated is crucial for security.
- Size: Vendoring can increase package size.
Example:
-
Scenario 1: If
requests
had no dependencies, bundling it with your package ensures the correct version is used. -
Scenario 2: Since
requests
relies on libraries likeurllib3
, including it may cause conflicts if other packages require different versions ofurllib3
.
Note: If you do vendoring, you need to comply with the vendoring policy. Check it here.
B. Virtual Environment Approach:
- Dependency conflicts are often out of your control, especially in third-party apps, even if virtual environments are used.
Issues:
- Out of Our Control: How users set up virtual environments is beyond our influence.
- Third-Party Apps: They might still face conflict issues, even in virtual environments.
C. Fork Approach:
- You can fork the conflicting package, rename it (e.g.,
mypackage-requests==2.26.0
), and use the forked version in your package.
Issues:
- Maintenance: Forking requires keeping the fork updated with the original package.
- Child Dependencies: If the forked package has dependencies, you may need to fork and manage those as well.
Conclusion:
Each approach has its benefits and challenges, and the choice depends on your specific use case and how much control you want over the dependencies. As a rule of thumb, it’s better to resolve conflicts by maintaining the package properly, ensuring compatibility with the broader Python ecosystem.
Resources:
Posted on September 5, 2024
Join Our Newsletter. No Spam, Only the good stuff.
Sign up to receive the latest update from our blog.
Related
November 19, 2024
November 15, 2024