If blockchain is the big new thing, why does it smell like snake oil?

alexkadis

Alex Kadis

Posted on February 23, 2019

If blockchain is the big new thing, why does it smell like snake oil?

snake oil
(Photo: Public Domain, via Atlas Obscura)

I think I get the basic concepts of what blockchain is and the technology behind it:

A ledger (database of transactions) that is distributed (a bunch of us in different locations have it), immutable (once some data is added it can't be removed), and encrypted (secure).

  • Given that it's a ledger, you can look back at what has happened before.
  • Given that it's distributed, no one person/company controls it.
  • Given that it's immutable, you can't go back and change past records.
  • Given that it's encrypted, no one can steal the stuff stored unless they have the keys to that specific data.

Despite all those things, it still seems like it's just a database with some simple problems:

  • People stink at data entry: Do techies really think that everyone is going to constantly track everything they do, and make sure that someone can go back and see exactly when something happened?
  • Theoretical security isn't the same as actual security: the transactions are supposedly private, but the entering of that data and reading it back certainly wouldn't be for many users. People will still use bad passwords.
  • It's expensive: a full public ledger would be huge, even if it's distributed, it has to be stored somewhere and hard drives ain't free. Not to mention, the energy usage is massive.
  • Technology changes, and what works now won't always work: What happens if the system used to enter the data is incompatible with the system used to read it back?

Why are so many people talking about it as a cure-all? What am I missing? Please help me out in the comments below.

πŸ’– πŸ’ͺ πŸ™… 🚩
alexkadis
Alex Kadis

Posted on February 23, 2019

Join Our Newsletter. No Spam, Only the good stuff.

Sign up to receive the latest update from our blog.

Related